Health Care Advocacy Group Could Shut Down

A state health care group that works to save Pennsylvanians money on health care could be out of a job.

The Pennsylvania Health Care Cost Containment Council employs more than 40 people in its Harrisburg office.

The group studies and compiles healthcare options without bias and is funded through the state budget.

The House and Senate have passed different bills authorizing the renewal of the group, but neither bill may make it into the budget in time.

Without state funding, the workers could be jobless until the General Assembly reconvenes in the fall.
Full Article and Source


The work of PHC4 is

The work of PHC4 is critically important to understanding and resolving some of the major issues surrounding Pennsylvania’s current health care system.

I invite some of the regular commentators on this blog (PD, Gent, Blackrobe,JP, etc.) to investigate this organization, and offer their analysis of its work. PHC4 is an independent council that provides accurate cost data for Pennsylvania hospitals, offers consumers information regarding the error rate of competing hospitals, and measures the effectiveness of cost reduction strategies. Its ongoing report on the cost of Hosipital-acquired infections, and methods to reduce their related costs is an internationally recognized source for information on the issue. I had the pleasure of hearing one of PHC4’s initial report regarding Hospital-accquired infections at a State Department of Health Conference in Pittsburgh back in 2006, and can attest to the professional respect this organization enjoys.

The Legislature needs to reauthorize PHC4 without delay. Pennsylvania needs to remain a leader in providing access to timely, accurate information relating to the performance of its hospitals.

JM

JM…Who in the House and

JM…Who in the House and Senate are friends of the PHC4?
JP

PHC4 friends?

I briefly served at the PA DOH between undergraduate and graduate course work to get some tangible experience in the policy field. That being said, I rarely dealt with the political side of the issues, and unfortunately could not give you a list of friends. Representative Eachus stands out as a supporter and may be able to provide info on PHC4’s future.

As a side note, KP has proven to be an excellent site to increase my personal political knowledge.

JM

Good Deal, JM.

JM –

I had heard of them, but I wasn’t terribly familiar with their work until I researched the group (as you suggested). I was very pleased with what I found. PHC4 appears to be a largely non-partisan advisory council whose sole purpose is to provide health care consumers in Pennsylvania with accurate cost and performance information in order for them to make the most appropriate choices. With regard to the current state of health care across the country today, all 50 states would benefit by having an outfit like this. PHC4 seems to be an illustration of what an “intelligent” health system (to borrow a phrase) should look like. I realize some look upon health care as a right, not a commodity, therefore cost should not enter into the equation. This is, at least in part, what drives the cost of health care skyward. If consumers don’t have the best information on prices and quality, they make imperfect decisions. This goes for health care just as much as anything else. Groups like PHC4 seem to be on the right track with their performance appraisals of state hospitals and other comprehensive reports on access and quality across the state. I don’t know if PHC4 does this (maybe you have an idea, JM), but I would like to see line-item listings for hospitals and other medical outfits across the state. Meaning, create an online database (easily accessible) that let’s the the public know exactly what each doctor, hospital, specialist, etc., charges for each procedure they offer. Part of keeping the cost of health care in check is cost containment. If consumers have the proper information, more often than not they’ll seek out the highest quality product for the lowest cost. When you consider that PHC4 likely saves more tax dollars than it uses, it seems like a worthy expenditure for taxpayers. I plan on contacting my state legislators today to ensure we keep it around. Thank you for the heads-up, JM.

PCH4’s website does offer

PCH4’s website does offer a database that provides access to all of their stattistics since 2000. Off the top of my head, they provide statistics on the financial health of hospitals and thier performance. When evaluating a hospital, one would be interested in both of these figures. And, if you actually do this you will find that some of the most finacially healthy hospitals have lower than expected performance scores, while some with less-than-desirable finacials offer some of the best performance.

I know for a fact that they do not have data on individual doctors and specialist due to privacy concerns, but they do have stats on “cardiac surgeons” with their individual indentifying information protected.

JM

Let everyone who want to be

Let everyone who want to be a doctor be a doctor. Let everyone who wants to open a hospital do so. Let everyone be free to choose their own caregiver.
Get rid of pernicious lawsuits with pie-in-the-sky damages.
Then, leave the whole medical thing alone.

Post new comment

  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <blockquote> <img> <div class="pullquote">
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • You can use Textile markup to format text.

More information about formatting options

We’ve developed a participation policy to help guide the tone of discussion in our community. Please read it to learn more about participating in Keystone Politics.